Architects at Play
As someone who works in architecture, I think about buildings and public spaces all the time. As a mother of young children, I often go to playgrounds. Playgrounds are not always interesting to me. One that we used to frequent was a giant fake log surrounded by fake grass in an upscale shopping area, but the kids loved it. They could spend an hour climbing on the log, jumping off it, and going underneath, which I always tried to discourage—it looked dirty. In the end, they did what they wanted.
Kids can play anywhere and they’re unpredictable, even if they’re generally well behaved. From a design perspective, this makes the playground a funny space. When architects set out to design a building, they don’t think of people scaling columns or sliding down the railings, but that’s what children do. Children don’t walk in straight lines so much as they bounce like atomic particles in a closed system. Out of curiosity, one friend of mine put a Fitbit on her son and in a few hours he had logged 14,000 steps compared to her 4,000. They had been together the entire time.

Designing for randomness must be counterintuitive to designers, especially architects. Architects love control. Those who go to architecture school and continue into practice become capable of overseeing construction. Construction documents are essentially like writing a recipe for a very special cake that someone else has to bake. If you are going to tell the contractor what to do, you must be exacting, unforgiving, always looking for mistakes, bordering on neurotic. Some of the most famous architects were a nightmare to work with: Frank Lloyd Wright, for example, designed not only the house but the furniture in it, along with instructions for the placement of the furniture. When one of his clients told him the roof was leaking above his head, he told him to move the chair.
Nicer, but still intense: Tadao Ando, who invented his own labor-intensive concrete mixing process and must travel with his own workers who also train and thoroughly vet local construction workers. Concrete is tricky because it can only be poured once and hides no flaws, and all of Ando’s concrete is perfect.
In 2004, Dwell magazine interviewed the offspring of three starchitects. One of them was Peter Eisenman’s daughter, Julie, who grew up in an apartment with all white walls and exclusively wore white until age three. Not very playground friendly, I’d like to think.
Is it any wonder that we didn’t talk much about playgrounds in architecture school? One of my professors mentioned the architect Herman Hertzberger in passing as someone who built elementary schools and understood the human scale. His work stood out to me enough that I went to the library and looked up his books, one of which was called Lessons for Students in Architecture. It features his work on Montessori schools in the Netherlands, which had lots of wonderful cozy nooks for play, reading, and classroom activities, along with wooden stadium stairs that he had to fight the Ministry of Education, teachers, and parents to keep. Adults believed the children would fall; the picture from Hertzberger’s book cover shows them stretched out on each step, listening to a teacher.
Fond memories of childhood influenced Hertzberger’s designs. He was raised in an urban housing project south of Amsterdam called Plan Zluid, where the sidewalks were wide and safe from cars. In a 2016 interview with Architecture and Education magazine, he described “sculpted, softly-rounded corner stones at the entrance. He could “still remember, something like 78 years later, the feeling of sitting on one.” Many visual artists have connected childhood to their adult sense of imagination and wonder, which is a necessity to make art. I’m surprised that more architects haven’t written about or acknowledged it.
Hertzberger also understood handrails. He said, “When you design a handrail in the public domain, you must realise that children are going to climb on it. . .I always think, ‘What are people going to do with it, apart from just using it as a handrail?’”
In architecture school, I also learned about Aldo Van Eyck, who was Hertzberger’s teacher and a founding member of Team 10—a group of architects who advocated for human centric architecture after finding modernism to be impersonal and sterile. It’s clear that Van Eyck had already tested these theories a few years earlier, starting in 1947, when he began his post at the Amsterdam Public Works department and started designing playgrounds. Playgrounds mattered tremendously in the post-war rebuilding of Amsterdam, where the city had been ravaged by war and residents had survived on tulip bulbs for food. Playgrounds brought life back to the urban fabric and helped foster community.
Over the next thirty years, Van Eyck designed over 700 playgrounds. Some were very small and featured little more than a soft-cornered rectangular sandbox. There were also circular sandboxes, arch-shaped climbing structures, single monkey bars, and stepping stones. They would be considered bare bones compared to today’s climbing walls, spiral-shaped poles, and zip lines. More remarkable were their placement within the city. True to his philosophy of favoring smaller urban interventions over grand, one-size-fits-all urbanism, Van Eyck placed his playgrounds in the forgotten, “in between” spaces—strips of land between roads, vacant lots, the side of buildings, old squares, and in neighborhood housing developments. The latter was sometimes requested by residents who had seen the success of his playgrounds in other parts of the city.
I live in Boston and it has 217 parks, playgrounds, and athletic fields according to the city website. We are lucky to have Frederick Law Olmstead’s Emerald necklace, which connects 1,000 acres of parks and waterways between Boston and Brookline, but for most of it, you can’t really understand that the parks are connected by walking. By contrast, Amsterdam has over 1200 playgrounds, ubiquitous enough that the city feels child-friendly. Van Eyck had wanted children to “become lords of the city,” a legacy that endures even though only seventeen of his original playgrounds survive in Amsterdam today.
Recently, I let my eldest child roam our neighborhood with other children of close friends, most of them preteens. We live in the city, and in a walkable neighborhood with a nice bookstore. The kids were given a bit of money, which they promptly used at the bodega to buy candy. They went to the bookstore only briefly and ended up at a playground. I know this playground and it’s nothing special–it has a big arch that doubles as a climbing apparatus and not much else. I did wonder why they went there if most of the kids didn’t climb it, given their age. Then I realized, where else would a group of kids go to be left alone? No matter how insignificant they may seem, playgrounds deserve their place.
Jamie Chan is a writer from Boston, MA. She received her MFA in fiction from Boston University and has an M. Arch from Yale. She serves as Studio AArde's marketing director. On weekends, she spends many hours watching her children play.





Comments